- Registration time
- Last login
- Online time
- 31 Hour
- Reading permission
I am both disappointed and bemused by temico's strident and exclusive views about English, my native tongue. In reply, I would offer the following points of information:
1. English was not "invented", it evolved, principally from Latin. Also, it continues to evolve - a glance at the regular additions to the Oxford English Dictionary bears particular witness to this fact.
2. Temico's attempt to distinguish between "native" English speakers - whom she incorrectly labels "Anglo-Saxons" - and people who converse in English from other countries, is also a myopic view. To lump (for example) US, UK and South African English together is quite outrageous, in that it ignores significant differences in accent and the culture which language reflects.
3. Temico's disparaging remarks about, for example, the standard of English on the Indian Sub-continent also displays a very exclusive attitude, bordering on racism. English does not belong to any race, or country, and it is open to anyone who wants to learn it, for whatever reason. I mentioned the Oxford English Dictionary (OED), and its task of identifying and recording new words, phrases and terms in the English idiom. They are not "gatekeepers", who decide whether a word should be added or not, but merely function to record any new words which are being used in English, anywhere in the world. This differs from the Academie Francaise, who do act as official arbiters of what new words may enter the French idiom. The OED's approach, therefore, is flexible, tolerant, and inclusive.
It is a pity that temico uses their impressive mastery of English to denigrate some of the principles outlined above.
English is for everyone, wherever they are, and for whatever purpose they wish to use it.