- Registration time
- Last login
- Online time
- 2 Hour
- Reading permission
Your English is so good that I had forgotten about you not being a native speaker. The bit about her being 14 was tongue-in-cheek. I don't actually think that she's 14, I was just using "14" in her username to draw attention to the fact that her reasoning was not quite up to the level of a 14 year old. I'll grant you that it may not have been as funny as I thought it was when I wrote it. I hope that's clear. For the avoidance of doubt I should also be clear that I'm not actually a dog, in the literal sense of the word.
I'm aware that The English Patient is based on real events but it is still a work of fiction and the words that were quoted were put into the mouth of a fictional character by an author who was in no way involved in the decision to bomb Japan. It is not a strong foundation for a debating point.
I'd still be interested to hear from you as to whether or not, in your opinion, the decision to bomb Hiroshima and Nagasaki to shock Japan into surrender was an incorrect choice. If you were in command in August 1945, would you have gone for the nukes or would you have ordered a land invasion of Japan at the cost of perhaps 10x as many Japanese lives as the Japanese Imperial Army fought to the last man or would you have chosen to back off and leave Hirohito's empire intact and a continuing threat to the rest of Asia? I can't imagine that, given the choice, many Chinese people in 1945 would have made the decision not to bomb Japan. If Japan had had the atom bomb they most certainly would have used it.
Of course, everyone here knows that Japan is the only country where atom bombs have been used in anger but almost all the atom bombs ever built were built by predominantly white countries (USA, UK, France) to point at other predominantly white countries (the Soviet Union and Warsaw Pact) and vice versa. It is notable also that the US did not use nukes in either Korea or Vietnam despite their humiliating withdrawal from the latter.
As a Brit I can say that we never dropped a nuke on any Asian country but the RAF did firebomb the hell out of Hamburg (1943) and Dresden and other German cities in 1945 in attacks which were almost as horrific as the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. It is claimed that 50,000 white German civilians were killed in Hamburg in a single night in 1943. In total between 400,000 and 600,000 Germans were killed and further 800,000 injured by British and US "area bombing" in Germany. We didn't hold back because they were white. I am very confident that if atom bombs had been fully ready to use before the defeat of Nazi Germany became inevitable then they would have been used.