Views: 21439|Replies: 116

Western media play along in the disinformation game [Copy link] 中文

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Gold Medal

Post time 2010-6-25 08:56:31 |Display all floors
This OP was published in today's Japan Times. It's from Gregory Clarke, a former Australian diplomat and a long time resident in Japan.
I'm not sure whether it will be allowed in this BBS. If not, it's also ok.



Are they being manipulated by governments? Or, are they just plain lazy, happy to go along with what everyone else is saying and what readers want to believe without wanting to look too closely into relevant background?

I refer to the way the Western media, both lately and in the past, have accepted blatant and often dangerous news distortions.

The No. 1 distortion remains the so-called massacre at Tiananmen Square. On the 21st anniversary of that alleged event earlier this month, the main news agencies still managed to preserve the fiction of Chinese troops marching into Beijing's iconic square and shooting down innocent students in the hundreds, if not thousands. This, despite all the reliable eyewitness reports, available on Google, that say almost nothing occurred in the square on the night of June 3-4, 1989.

What happened was quite different: There was wild shooting on roads leading to the square by soldiers retaliating for vicious firebomb attacks by angry citizens on units sent to remove protesting students who had been allowed to occupy the square for weeks while regime moderates tried vainly to negotiate the reforms the students wanted. Many died as a result, including soldiers incinerated in their trucks and other vehicles.

But never mind the facts. The fantasy story makes for much better reading. It also gave the European nations an excuse to blacklist China for arms sales and even for the riot control equipment that might have prevented the mayhem.

A detailed 1998 study in the Columbia Journalism Review titled "Reporting the Myth of Tiananmen, and the Price of a Passive Press," by Jay Mathews, Washington Post former bureau chief in Beijing (also available on Google) traces the massacre myth to a front-page story in Hong Kong that was flashed quickly around the world as fact by news agencies. My not uninformed guess says it was probably planted by either Western or Taiwanese intelligence agencies. The alleged author has never been found.

Closer to home, we have the reports of the March torpedo attack on a South Korean warship, killing 46 seamen. Western media blasting North Korea for the attack make little or no mention of the fact that it was in disputed waters and that, if caused by North Korea, it would almost certainly have been retaliation for a November 2009 South Korean attack on a North Korean patrol boat in the same area, also with casualties.

Even less mention is made of the fact that the waters are disputed because of an arbitrary line drawn by the United States under the 1953 Korean War armistice. Determining the correct line would be a key item in the peace agreement that North Korea wants but that the U.S. has delayed, hoping for regime collapse in the North.

There are even doubts whether there was an attack. Sweden, the only neutral member in an international group investigating the affair, withdrew from the final report (see the article by John McGlynn in the June 7 Asia-Pacific Journal). Two other possible causes for the sinking have been put forward, but little of this finds mention in Western media, where calls for strong retaliation and U.N. condemnation against North Korea wax large.

It's a similar story with regard to the media fuss over Chinese naval activity in the East China Sea. China has a not-invalid claim to a large Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) in the East China sea even if it conflicts with Japan's median line claim.

China can hardly be expected to remain immobile while Japan acts as if its own claim is set in stone, especially since Beijing, unlike Tokyo, seeks a compromise joint development agreement between the rival claims.

The western Pacific coral reef of Okinotorishima presents a similar dilemma for Beijing. China does not dispute Japan's ownership of the reef. But it could hardly remain silent after the Japanese military earlier this year landed troops on the reef in a bid to support Tokyo's claim for an encircling 400,000-square-km EEZ — a claim that contradicts international law, which states that rocks unable to sustain economic activity cannot have an EEZ.

But one would have to look hard for any mention of these crucial details in the Western media, where increasingly China is portrayed as expansionist and a future military threat.

Many Japanese media were happy to use the biased versions of these incidents to accuse the Hatoyama administration of ignoring Chinese and North Korean threats, and to pressure it into agreeing to the relocation of a U.S Marine base to Henoko, Okinawa.


Can't we have an end to this kind of media bias? Media acceptance of Cold War disinformation operations by both sides cost millions of lives and decades of stunted economic growth. Working in Canberra during those years, I saw close up how slanted material from allegedly impartial academics and think tanks was pushed into the media, and used. Western disinformation efforts during the Kosovo and Iraq wars were equally harmful.

With South Ossetia, we had the remarkable sight of the main U.S. and U.K. media telling us that Russia had attacked Georgia when it was almost the complete opposite — a claim that could easily have led to a revived Cold War.

Even worse was the 1962 claim that China had attacked India when in it was the complete opposite — a false claim that indirectly led to the Vietnam War.

Today, over Iran, we have a similar media disinformation war under way, financed in part by CIA funds, reported American award-winning commentator Seymour Hersh in 2008. Maybe it's time for the media to clean up their act a bit.




The Japan Times: Friday, June 25, 2010
(C) All rights reserved

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 4

Post time 2010-6-25 15:24:05 |Display all floors
It appear that Gregory Clark is still writing about political discrimination against China
Malaysian-born Chinese

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Gold Medal

Post time 2010-6-25 16:07:31 |Display all floors
Originally posted by taikor at 2010-6-25 16:24
It appear that Gregory Clark is still writing about political discrimination against China



Not only but also.

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post time 2010-6-25 16:17:07 |Display all floors
Are you for real ?   There's a ----load of reports on google right now about the shootings from all kinds of people, some who were actually there as students themselves.

The only disinformation i  can see right now is yours.

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post time 2010-6-25 16:17:54 |Display all floors
*S-hitload.

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 4

Post time 2010-6-25 16:29:54 |Display all floors
There was no 'massacre' by the troops.

People gets killed in a social violence. You may send me the sources via p.m.

Btw, are you that James St. George guy from the BBC forum? Friend of Electric Hermit?
Malaysian-born Chinese

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Medal Medal of honor Gold Medal July's Best Writer 2012 October's Best Writer 2012

Post time 2010-6-25 16:44:46 |Display all floors

That will be interesting.................

If the CD is brave enough to run with this.

It is axiomatic that this will become a real topic one day.

Why not now?

And a chance to find out why some claim an enormous death toll, and in the same place claim the thousands of this same toll living abroad who cannot return home.   

Have the cake and eat it.

Yes, indeed.

The Gulf of Tonkin.
Sarah Jessica Parker
Blackwater now Xe

The list goes on.....

How about.......

In 2005, the newly-elected Ahmedinjad was giving a speech at a conference in Tehran about Zionism. He quoted the founder of the Islamic Revolution, Imam Khomeini, and said, "Imam ghoft een rezhim-e ishghalgar-e qods bayad az safheh-ye ruzgar mahv shavad." A direct translation of this is: "The Imam [Khomeini] said [the] regime occupying Jerusalem must vanish from the page of time." The words "wiped off the map" are not to be found in that sentence, and any amateur translator will tell you nagsheh, the Persian term for map, is not found in that sentence.

There is also no evidence of atomic weapons being made.

Yet the media are getting the western world ready for the next pre-emptive strike.


The western media........... and its readers ..........          

Use magic tools Report

You can't reply post until you log in Log in | register

BACK TO THE TOP
Contact us:Tel: (86)010-84883548, Email: blog@chinadaily.com.cn
Blog announcement:| We reserve the right, and you authorize us, to use content, including words, photos and videos, which you provide to our blog
platform, for non-profit purposes on China Daily media, comprising newspaper, website, iPad and other social media accounts.